Part 103 ultralights seem eclipsed by the attention awarded to Light-Sport Aircraft. But a Wichita tech entrepreneur who sold his business is now pursuing aviation focused on the airplane formerly known as the Kitfox Lite. *** James Wiebe bought the rights to the single seater, opened shop as Belite Aircraft, and immediately started replacing aluminum and wood components with carbon fiber. The result is a genuinely light aircraft than can make Part 103 with several pounds to spare. *** On July 4th, as America was blowing off fireworks, James fired up his 28-horsepower Zanzottera MZ-34 engine to make his maiden flight. “While the rest of the country was focused on celebrating independence, I was experiencing it, making lazy circles in the sky above Jabara Airport,” Wiebe expressed. As flown, the airplane weighed approximately 245 pounds and that included the optional rear window and a full VFR panel.
none
Independence Day Treat! — Past LSA Leader Returns
Some have likely forgotten that the Allegro was the third Special Light-Sport Aircraft ever certified, following only Evektor’s SportStar and Flight Design’s CT. It was also a market leader early on…in fact, it did so well, Fantasy Air (the now-bankrupt Czech designer and producer) still holds the #12 position even without a sale in nearly two years. *** The founding company’s troubled history is now being replaced with an all-American manufacturing effort based on the revised Allegro 2007 model that saw improvements to better suit the American market. Allegro USA LLC, the newly-formed company, announced in June that Allegro will now be built completely in Roseburg, Oregon. Allegro USA believes this will eliminate concerns for warranty, parts, delivery, and financing. *** Some LSA suppliers may be cautious in today’s economy but Allegro USA is taking strides to regain its market position.
Zenith & AMD Update CH 601 & CH 701 to 650 & 750
Consider the Zenair / Zenith / AMD family of enterprises… Following family patriarch, Canadian Chris Heintz (the designer) are Missouri-based son Sebastien Heintz (the kit supplier) and Georgia-based son Mathieu Heintz (the aircraft producer). Another sibling, Michael Heintz acts as a dealer in California. The Heintzes also have a family of aircraft models. *** Zenith Aircraft Company supplies kits for the 2-seat CH-650 and CH-750 plus the 4-seat CH-801. AMD supplies fully built versions of the 650 and 750 plus the Part 23-certified Alarus. In 2008 the family companies upgraded their top sellers: CH-601 and CH-701. Of these the CH-750 LS is the newest Special LSA on our list. *** Though it visually looks like the CH 701, the 750 LS stands two inches taller and is 11 inches longer with a 2-foot 9-inch greater wingspan, bumping wing area to 144 square feet from 122 on the CH 701.
FAA Begins “Assessment” of LSA Industry
At Oshkosh, FAA held a meeting to announce their LSA Assessment Project. The agency that gave birth to Light-Sport Aircraft in the summer of 2004 is now embarking on a fact-finding tour they say will judge the “health of the industry,” part of their “aviation safety oversight.” Sounds rather ominous, doesn’t it? However, officials also stated clearly and repeatedly, “What this assessment and evaluation is not is an individual Light-Sport manufacturer’s compliance audit.” *** Indeed, Terry Chasteen, the new head LSA man in the Small Aircraft Directorate characterized the day-long visits by two teams of two inspectors as benign. He’ll be joined by Tom Gunnarson, former president of LAMA now with the LSA office. The visits started this week at Tecnam’s U.S. quarters; AMD, Aircraft Manufacturing and Design; Fantasy Air USA / LSA America; and P&M Aviation USA.
Rotary Power for M-Squared’s Part 103 Ultralight
In the late 1970s, Mazda popularized the rotary engine for their RX-7 sports car. Such engines are particularly known for their smooth running operation. Many aviators can appreciate low-vibration powerplants but especially those flying the lightest of recreational aircraft, namely Part 103 machines. *** Now, M-Squared has partnered to offer such a combination. Revolution Rotary Engines Inc., a Canadian-based manufacturing company located in Markham, Ontario connected with M-Squared‘s Paul Mather to exploit the possibilities of rotary power. At Sun ‘n Fun 2008, M-Squared showed a single place, strutted Breese with the R301A single cylinder rotary engine supplying 35 horsepower. Installed on M-Squared’s lightweight Breese SS (single seat), the aircraft is said to remain within 103’s tight parameters (assuming the buyer does not insist on options and accessories that would bump it over weight). *** The single rotor aircraft engine looks compact and weighs a reported 40 pounds.
Big Crowds at the Sun ‘n Fun LSA Mall
Sun ‘n Fun 2008 is history, but planning is already underway for the 2009 event. Event boss John Burton confirmed we will again have the LAMA-hosted LSA Mall right at the front gate next April 21-26. A major success at this year’s Lakeland, Florida airshow, the industry Mall presentation featured 17 Special Light-Sport Aircraft. Weather prevented Fantasy Air’s Allegro from attending. Two days before the event, a tornado crushed a Sting S3 planned for display. And work at Quicksilver Manufacturing postponed the exhibit of the GT500 (they’re finishing SLSA approval, reports national sales manager, Todd Ellefson). *** The 17 who were in the ’08 LSA Mall enjoyed significant traffic all week and virtually every visitor to Sun ‘n Fun was at least exposed to Light-Sport Aircraft in a wide variety (although we were not able to enlist any trike or powered parachute companies).
Ultralights Seek SLSA Approval; May Sell ELSA Kits
Taking a kit aircraft company to full ASTM approval is a very big decision for small companies. Simply assuring you have documents to support a declaration is, by itself, a major task. Then comes a decision about fully building or going the Experimental LSA kit route. A company must first fully build and certify at least one Special LSA, but once done, they can elect to provide a kit only…or to factory build and supply kits. Small shops could fully build 20-30 SLSA and supply additional ELSA kits and parts to make a healthy business. *** We may finally see such entries. Recently I wrote an updated pilot report on the T-Bird I from Indy Aircraft. Boss Bret Kivell said Indy is working on approval. As an ELSA, the single seater could be HKS (four-stroke) powered, which would make it one sweet sport aircraft. Likewise development is underway at Paul Mather’s M-Squared Aircraft where his Sport 1000 could gain SLSA approval later this year.
Lockwood to Help Educate A&Ps on Rotax Powerplants
A&P acceptance (or lack thereof) is a leading reason for Cessna’s decision to use the Continental O-200D in Skycatcher. Surveys through their Cessna Pilot Centers showed that a majority of FAA-licensed mechanics preferred an engine they already know. Most lack knowledge of the Rotax 9-series that powers the majority of the LSA fleet. And when an expert knows little about a new product, human nature compels him to resist. *** Trying to educate A&Ps on the best-selling LSA engine is one task of Rotax service center operator, Phil Lockwood. This winter, he’ll be giving hourlong presentations for A&Ps (and owners), trying to encourage to A&Ps to take a pair of two-day courses to bring them up to speed with the Austrian engines. *** Of 62 presently approved SLSA models, only 8 (13%) use another engine (Continental or Jabiru). Starting in 1973 with the ultralight market, Rotax has produced more than 125,000 aircraft engines.
Getting Ready for Sebring’s LSA Expo #4
Over January 17-20, 2008 every significant company in Light-Sport Aircraft will be in Sebring, Florida. The Sebring Expo preludes with an ASTM meeting. During the event LAMA hosts its annual member meeting and dinner plus its board will meet. EAA will organize a slate of info forums. Importantly, vendors can deliver demo flights all day every day. *** Event Chairman Bob Wood reported, “Cirrus Design is the most recent addition to the stellar group of companies now sponsoring the event. They join Cessna, Garmin, The Southern Ford Dealers, and others.” *** Sebring #4 appears bound for new records. Paid exhibit space available increased again in 2008. “We are up nearly 30% in spaces over 2007, and now nearly every one of those is booked,” said Wood. Most of the 47 companies and the 59 models that have achieved SLSA status can be found at Sebring making it the largest collection of LSA anywhere.
Bright Yellow Fk9 Was a Hit at Sebring’s Expo
He could see the benefit for his company’s sales, so Fk Leichtflugzeuge — or FK Lightplanes — president Peter Funk came from Speyer, Germany to support his new American importer, Tony Anderson of Fk Lightplanes USA. Tony brought his family operation to Sebring and their classy display at the main intersection of the U.S. Sport Aviation Expo attracted the attention of many in attendance. The intensely yellow Fk9 turned heads and lifted 25 pilots who took demo flights during Sebring. “I was very happy to see how well our high wing model was received,” said a smiling Peter Funk. The Fk9 Mk IV is a well-evolved design. Since the Mk I model flew in 1989, more than 300 aircraft have been delivered. The latest generation Mk IV features a wider cockpit area, four inches more legroom, and improved seat comfort. Unlike many LSA, Fk9 is available as a kit, fast-build kit, or ready-to-fly SLSA.
LSA’s Newest Entry…Cirrus Imports a Beauty
EAA AirVenture is full of surprises. We all knew about Cessna’s confirmed LSA entry (though we had to travel to Oshkosh to see its new Skycatcher). Plenty of other surprises are expected. But one that caught almost everybody unawares was the Cirrus Design entry to aviation’s newest segment. *** They’ll import — and modify, or “Cirrus-ize” — FK Lightplane‘s gorgeous Fk14 Polaris. Cirrus cofounder Dale Klapmeier said, “The Polaris is the basis for a Cirrus LSA, which we’ll call the SRS…for Sport.” The successful Duluth builder wanted a low-wing composite to revise into a low-cost trainer in which new pilots can begin moving toward later ownership of a SR20/22 or the Cirrus Jet. *** “We want a fun, exciting LSA that’s also a good trainer,” added Dale. “We want to appeal all those young at heart potential aviators, including kids. Aviation needs to attract more pilots.” Cirrus previewed their new SRS at their company display right at the entrance to Oshkosh on opening-day Monday.
Float-Flying the M-Squared Sprint 1000
Seating | 2, side-by-side |
Empty weight | 465 pounds 1 |
Gross weight | 1,400 pounds |
Wingspan | 32 feet, 9 inches |
Wing area | 180 square feet |
Wing loading | 7.8 pounds/square foot |
Length | 19 feet |
Height | 7 feet, 10 inches |
Kit type | Fully assembled 2 |
Build time | 40 hours 2 |
Notes: | 1 Before floats; contact factory for all-up weight with straight or amphibious floats 2 Builder-assistance program offered by M-Squared, as required for N-numbered aircraft like the Sprint 1000. Contact factory for further details and scheduling. |
Standard engine | Rotax 582 |
Power | 65 hp |
Power loading | 21.2 pounds/hp |
Cruise speed | 50-65 mph |
Never exceed speed | 94 mph 1 |
Rate of climb at gross | 650 fpm 1 |
Takeoff distance at gross | 135 feet 1 |
Landing distance at gross | 60 feet 1 |
Notes: | 1 Before floats; contact factory for performance with straight or amphibious floats |
Standard Features | 65-hp 2-stroke Rotax 582 engine, Warp Drive prop, EIS instrument info system, 15-inch main tires on aluminum wheels with 6-inch drum brakes, 13-inch nose tire and aluminum wheel, hand brake, steel cage surrounding pilot, adjustable strut fittings, high-lift airfoil with 14-inch rib spacing, wing-mounted fuel cells. |
Options | 81-hp Rotax 912 and 100-hp Rotax 912S engines, electric starter (standard on 912 models), pilot enclosures, additional instrumentation and EIS with digital instrument gauges, ballistic parachute, 16-gallon wing-mounted fuel cells, stainless steel main frame (especially useful for salt-water float operations). |
Construction | Aluminum airframe, Dacron wing and tail coverings, steel components including pilot cage. Made and distributed in the USA by American-owned company. |
Design
Cosmetic appearance, structural integrity, achievement of design goals, effectiveness of aerodynamics, ergonomics.
Pros - The Sprint 1000 on inflatable Full Lotus floats is a rugged, well-proven design with fully strutted construction preferred by many pilots. Full Lotus floats work well with the single-surface wing, helping the design to take off in a short run. Design is especially durable with large diameter tubing.
Cons - Struts may be preferred but they're heavier than cable bracing. Open cockpit has lots of appeal for a sport floatplane but not all pilots enjoy the sensation. Longer field assembly required; no folding wings.
Systems
Subsystems available to pilot such as: Flaps; Fuel sources; Electric start; In-air restart; Brakes; Engine controls; Navigations; Radio; (items covered may be optional).
Pros - Except for float structure - that you may have to create - the Sprint 1000 is very simple. Wing fuel tanks hold 16 gallons. In-flight trim is standard on 2-seat M-Squared models. Electric starting and full amphibious gear also available.
Cons - Robustly built airframe is heavy for the type and with additional amphibious gear empty weight is even greater. Pull starting on a floatplane may be a problem for some pilots.
Cockpit/Cabin
Instrumentation; Ergonomics of controls; Creature comforts; (items covered may be optional).
Pros - Stainless steel (optional) pilot cage in tandem sets of pilot-surrounding structure add to a secure feeling. Occupants easily share center stick during training. Very easy entry especially compared to other floatplanes. Instruments mounted overhead away from possible water damage (except for ASI).
Cons - Wide-open cockpits aren't for everyone, which may affect resale. Taller or shorter pilots have neither seat nor rudder adjustment. Seat is angled back generously, perhaps too steeply for some pilots. No cargo area.
Ground Handling
Taxi visibility; Steering; Turn radius; Shock absorption; Stance/Stability; Braking.
Pros - Full Lotus inflatable floats are popular for the soft ride they deliver and for their durability; combine well with the Sprint 1000's short run. Full Lotus floats support walking well. Amphib nosewheel option is steerable and main gear stance is very wide. No water rudder needed with the Sprint close-coupled rudder.
Cons - Lack of water rudders means you must throttle the engine to produce enough airflow; makes beachings and dockings somewhat more challenging. Electric starting is even more valuable on a floatplane where pull starting can be more difficult.
Takeoff/Landing
Qualities; Efficiency; Ease; Comparative values.
Pros - The Sprint 1000's ease of takeoff demonstrates the value of single-surface, high-lift wings; even more true on water operations. Powerful acceleration with 2-stroke Rotax 582. You set a modest pitch angle and the Sprint 1000 flies off the water smoothly. Approaches can be made at 40 to 45 mph.
Cons - As with most similar designs, the Sprint 1000 bleeds energy quickly so you must maintain good speed right down to the surface. Slips are largely ineffective in this type aircraft (though they're hardly needed, especially for water operations where you slow quickly on the surface).
Control
Quality and quantity for: Coordination; Authority; Pressures; Response; and Coupling.
Pros - The Sprint 1000 controls reasonably well, thanks to large ailerons, lower dihedral, and stiffer airframe (though the weight of floats and structure diminishes response somewhat). Precision turns are easily achieved. Responds quickly to rudder-only input. Good crosswind capabilities.
Cons - Due to rudder's influence on controls, you use the pedals significantly in coordinated turns. Pitch is more sensitive due to the closely coupled tail (the same quality that helps in water taxiing). Adverse yaw is clearly present on the Sprint 1000, despite low dihedral.
Performance
Climb; Glide; Sink; Cruise/stall/max speeds; Endurance; Range; Maneuverability.
Pros - Flying over water at low heights is especially fun in a slower flying Sprint 1000 floatplane. Water run is short with 2-stroke Rotax 582. Climb is better than 500 fpm even with float/structure weight. Good floatplane trainer for new water pilots. Can cruise at 60 to 65 mph.
Cons - Speed range on the Sprint 1000 is shallow, though typical for the design type. Max speed is only 94 mph; 60 mph is pretty slow for cross-country flying (though floatplanes are often flown too far). Consumes plenty of fuel due to its low speed and heavier weight.
Stability
Stall recovery and characteristics; Dampening; Spiral stability; Adverse yaw qualities.
Pros - Stalls in any configuration were modest events. Steel around the cockpit provides good occupant protection. M-Squared supports use of, and has a good installation for ballistic parachutes. Four-point pilot restraints are generally not used on seaplanes, though M-Squared normally supplies them.
Cons - Stalls break while they don't on the lighter land model. This heavier Sprint 1000 floatplane wallows somewhat just before stall. With the high engine and thrust line, the Sprint 1000 with Rotax 582 noses over on throttle up. Adverse yaw is significant.
Overall
Addresses the questions: "Will a buyer get what he/she expects to buy, and did the designer/builder achieve the chosen goal?"
Pros - Almost 10 years old, M-Squared has become an established brand with proven products, made highly robust with large diameter tubing. Strutted look is what many buyers seek. Larger fuel tanks are standard. Prices are reasonable though you must build from kit.
Cons - Without an optional enclosure, you'll be limited to warmer climates or shorter seasons in this wide-open design.
“Air in your hair! Space on your face! A breeze on your knees!” A former colleague of mine used to repeat this short mantra to illustrate the joy of open-cockpit flying. It was catchy and engaging and his customers liked it. With 15 Light-Sport Aircraft now possessing their FAA Special Light-Sport Aircraft (SLSA) airworthiness certificates, not a single one is open cockpit, though the IndUS Thorpedo, Legend Cub, and Tecnam Sierra can enjoy partially open cockpits. Special Light-Sport Aircraft will eventually add more of this genre of light aircraft but one of the beauties of FAA’s new regulation is that it does not eliminate two previous categories: Amateur-built 51% kits or Part 103-compliant ultralights. With 21¼4 years left before operators of 2-seat 496-pound empty weight ultralight exempt trainers must register in FAA’s new Light-Sport Aircraft category, and with 41¼4 years left while these machines can be used for compensated training flights, the segment still has lots of life remaining.
Ultralight Adventures (and More) in Downtown Miami
More than a decade ago, Tony Anderson started teaching students how to fly on floats. Today, his family enterprise spreads across three aviation businesses. In a recent visit I was most impressed to witness what the Andersons have built. From their home base with hangar right on an in-town lake to the North Perry Airport FBO to a downtown Miami seaplane operation, Tony and son Adriel have this major tropical metro covered. At North Perry they also run their FK Lightplanes USA enterprise, importing and selling the Fk9, Polaris, and Comet. On my visit the Fk9 used for training was constantly busy plus I saw two brand-new Fk9s available for immediate delivery. Across the city in downtown Miami, Tony and Adriel operate several Drifter 912s on straight Lotus floats. Adriel directs this training and intro lesson operation. He’s accumulated a rather astounding 5,000 hours in one particular Drifter and it isn’t the only aircraft he flies.
FK9 Now Imported with Folding, Shorter-Span Wings
The feature of folding wings is credited with the sale of many aircraft by brands such as Kitfox and Kolb (among numerous others). Promoting the Sport Pilot certificate, I’ve visited flight schools at busy airports where one of the obstacles to growth — and to adding a LSA as a trainer — has been a lack of more space to hangar their fleet. Now with FK Lightplanes USA bringing in their first two FK9 Mark IV B models, this could change. *** The Florida-based importer for the German design used in many of that country’s flight schools recently took delivery of its first two “B” versions configured as they will routinely import them. Their selection includes two-feet less span with the 100-hp Rotax 912S and folding wings as the standard model (though the 80-horse, non-folding wing models can be special ordered). The first customer, taking both aircraft, was the cooperative LetsFly.org that helps buyers share ownership of LSA and other aircraft.
Germany’s FK Lightplanes Gains a U.S. Distributor
For years, FK Lightplanes has been a leading supplier in Europe. Designs are created by Otto and Peter Funk, the father and son team that introduced the FK9 Mark IV (all-round use and trainer design), the FK12 Comet (enclosed, folding biwing), and the elegant FK14 Polaris, a modern LSA candidate available in tricycle gear or taildragger. FK planes appointed Wings of Paradise their American representative. Based in south Florida at North Perry Airport (HWO), Wings of Paradise is a longtime ultralight dealer and provider of lessons on Miami area beaches. FK Lightplanes sells models like the FK14 Polaris in 51% kit form, fast-build form, and it is available ready-to-fly. Wings of Paradise is working with the German producer to meet SLSA standards; the design is certified under Germany’s Microlight rules. E-mail contact.
FK9 Wins SLSA Certification
FK Lightplanes FK9 Mk IV becomes our 21st SLSA since April 15 (a rate of 3 per month!). A longtime ultralight enthusiast with a list of FAA ratings, importer Tony Anderson has moved fast since securing distribution of Germany’s FK Lightplanes. Since my SPLOG two days ago, Tony was able to confirm by copy of his Airworthiness Certificate the SLSA approval for the FK9 Mk IV on November 17th. Here is a proven microlight design built very lightly (590 pounds empty) using fiberglass over steel construction. Powered by a Rotax 912 or 912S, FK9 cruises at 105 knots and climbs 1,500 fpm at gross (with 100 hp engine at 1,146 pounds gross weight). In service for many years in Germany, FK9 is quite popular with flight schools. It also has the slickest of wing folding mechanisms. A single person can unhook the wing — from the tip — and fold the wing.
FK Lightplanes FK-14
Meet the top model from FK Lightplanes. The frenzy over the FAA’s light-sport aircraft (LSA) and sport pilot proposal continues. Pilots from ultralight to general aviation are discussing it, and the new rule may be released soon, according to those aware of FAA deliberations. We may be about to witness the birth of a new aviation segment. But unlike its predecessors, this one may come with aircraft ready to meet the need. An interesting twist on this American story is that European designs may dominate the first aircraft to fly under the rule, providing they comply with the consensus standards currently being drafted by the community. This month, let’s meet one of the sleekest, FK Lightplanes’ Polaris FK-14 from Germany. A Family Business Peter and Otto Funk are the family members behind the Polaris and its siblings, the high-wing FK-9 (which has gone through three distinct versions) and the folding-wing biplane FK-12.
Fk-9 Mark III
Empty weight | 572 lbs |
Gross weight | 992 lbs (European Microlight model) |
Wingspan | 32.1 ft |
Wing area | 125 sq ft |
Cruise speed | 120-135 mph |
Stall Speed (Flaps) | 40 mph |
Rate of climb at gross | 1,100 fpm |
Takeoff distance at gross | 395 ft |
Landing distance at gross | 500 ft |
Range (powered) | (standard tank) 500 mi |
Notes: | The Mark III model has now been updated to the Mark IV (report to follow). Fk-9 Mark IV has been approved as a Special Light-Sport Aircraft (11/05) |
Sleek composite microlight performs like a GA aircraft In the Dec. 11 Flyer, I wrote about the Albatros, which I call a hybrid ultralight because it bridges older tube-and-rag ultralights and new all-composite models. This month we look at the German-built FK-9 from B&F Technik. A new breed with an interesting history, it too emerged from an earlier design. In fact, the FK-9 shown in photos that accompany this story is the glass-fiber Mark 3. Its predecessors, the Mark 1 and Mark 2, used fabric skins, putting them more in the hybrid category. To review briefly, hybrid microlights are flying machines that employ the best ideas of familiar ultralight designs, such as sewn Dacron wings and aluminum airframes, yet combine those proven components with composite fuselages and welded steel parts. Simple construction keeps many small builders in business. Conversely, the composite microlights are typically all-composite designs (or composite over steel) using newer construction technology and techniques.
Breese HKS Sidebar
On the Horizon at M-Squared Paul Mather has another airplane in the works at his Alabama company. Called the AeroTug, it made its first public appearance in the summer of ’03 in Wisconsin. Once called “Breese AT,” the new entry is built by M-Squared in a deal involving former Second Chantz Aircraft Recovery Systems owner John Dunham. Dunham says he approached Mather and M-Squared. They agreed that Mather will build the customized rig and Dunham will market and distribute it. Already very familiar with M-Squared airplanes, Dunham leases one he owns to TV production studios as a filming platform. He explains, “I’ve been working with Paul to develop a new tug ultralight to compete with the Dragonfly. We will be doing flight and hang glider tow testing in Alabama, and then I will be flying it around to all the Florida parks to show it off. I’ll be the exclusive marketing agent for this aircraft.” In explaining his request to Mather’s company, Dunham said that he wanted it to be, “…based on the M-Squared Breese single-seat design with the 2-place, single-surface, slow, strutted wing, plus a Maule-type tow hook release under the rudder, tundra tires, and a specially-built Rotax 670 – almost 100 hp at the same weight as the Rotax 582.” About this hybrid model Mather says, “She’ll climb all day at 25 mph while towing a hang glider.
Breese With HKS Engine Is A Winner
Seating | 1 |
Empty weight | 400 pounds |
Gross weight | 750 pounds |
Wingspan | 30 feet |
Wing area | 168 square feet |
Wing loading | 4.4 pounds per square foot |
Length | 19 feet |
Height | 7 feet 10 inches |
Kit type | Fully Assembled 1 |
Build time | 40 hours 1 |
Notes: | 1 Builder-assistance program offered by M-Squared, as required for N-numbered aircraft like the HKS-powered Breese DS. Contact factory for further details. |
Standard engine | 4-stroke HKS 700E |
Power | 60 hp |
Power loading | 12.5 pounds per hp |
Cruise speed | 65 mph |
Never exceed speed | 74 mph |
Rate of climb at gross | 925 fpm |
Takeoff distance at gross | 80 feet |
Landing distance at gross | 60 feet |
Standard Features | 60-hp HKS 700E engine with electric starter, Powerfin prop, EIS info system, 15-inch main tires on aluminum wheels with 6-inch drum brakes, 13-inch nose tire and aluminum wheel, hand brake, steel cage surrounding pilot, adjustable strut fittings, high-lift airfoil with 14-inch rib spacing, wing-mounted fuel cells. |
Options | 65-hp 2-stroke Rotax 582, electric starter (standard on HKS), pilot enclosures, additional instrumentation and EIS with digital gauges, ballistic parachute, 16-gallon wing-mounted fuel cells, stainless steel main frame. |
Construction | Aluminum airframe, Dacron wing and tail coverings, steel components including pilot cage. Made and distributed in the USA by American-owned company. |
Design
Cosmetic appearance, structural integrity, achievement of design goals, effectiveness of aerodynamics, ergonomics.
Pros - The Breese DS with an HKS is an upgraded single-seat design using M-Squared's fully strutted construction preferred by many pilots. Useful load is 350 pounds; great for large pilots. Sturdy, tubing- braced design helps the Breese DS to be more durable. Four-stroke power is popular with most pilots.
Cons - Builder-assistance program required to qualify for N-numbers as required on this slightly heavy model. Open cockpit will appeal to some but not all pilots, possibly affecting resale. One-hour field assembly required, as wings don't fold. Qualification for proposed Light-Sport Aircraft still being investigated.
Systems
Subsystems available to pilot such as: Flaps; Fuel sources; Electric start; In-air restart; Brakes; Engine controls; Navigations; Radio; (items covered may be optional).
Pros - Electric starting comes standard with the HKS engine. Also standard with the HKS-powered Breese are wing fuel tanks holding 16 gallons. Optional systems can be added, as the Breese DS HKS must be N-numbered. Payload remains more than 250 pounds even with full fuel in long range tanks.
Cons - In-flight trim is standard on 2-seat M-Squared models but not available on the single-seat Breese (though it's hardly needed). Airframe is a weighty 400 pounds. I had enough trouble initially gripping the brake lever that two hands were needed.
Cockpit/Cabin
Instrumentation; Ergonomics of controls; Creature comforts; (items covered may be optional).
Pros - Stainless steel (optional) pilot cage in tandem sets of pilot-surrounding structure. Four-point seat belts are standard. Side stick is comfortably placed. Optional pilot enclosure is available for those in colder climates. All switches were easily reached (though you can't read their purpose when fully belted).
Cons - Wide-open cockpits aren't for everyone, possibly affecting resale. Seat is angled back generously, perhaps too steeply for some pilots. No radio or GPS locations available; must use tube clamps or innovate your own panel. Seat not adjustable (nor are the rudder pedals) for pilots of different height.
Ground Handling
Taxi visibility; Steering; Turn radius; Shock absorption; Stance/Stability; Braking.
Pros - Very large tires on big aluminum wheels (13-inch nose and 15-inch mains) provide a nice taxi ride. Suspension is air in the tires and tubing flex, but it felt sufficient. Steerable nosewheel is standard, also built from stainless in the test Breese. Drum brakes are standard. Responsive ground steering.
Cons - M-Squared models have no bungee or other suspension, just air in the tires and flex in the tubes. Nondifferential brakes (though steering is quite good). Brake handle was difficult for me to grip (though some adjustments may be possible).
Takeoff/Landing
Qualities; Efficiency; Ease; Comparative values.
Pros - Ease of takeoff can't get much better. Ground roll is only 80 feet at gross weight. Powerful acceleration with HKS engine. You only need to set a modest pitch angle and the Breese DS will fly off the runway. You can make approaches at speeds down close to 30 mph for very short runway capability.
Cons - The Breese DS bleeds energy quickly so you must keep up your speed before touchdown. Open cockpit aircraft suggests a full-face helmet to ensure no bird or insect distraction. Slips are largely ineffective in this type aircraft (though slow approach speed makes this a small concern).
Control
Quality and quantity for: Coordination; Authority; Pressures; Response; and Coupling.
Pros - The Breese DS controls are quite responsive, thanks to well-sized ailerons, lower dihedral, and stiffer airframe, which offers a more secure anchor for the control surfaces. Precision turns are easily achieved. Responds quickly to rudder-only input. Good crosswind capabilities.
Cons - Pitch was more sensitive than I recall, perhaps due to a closely coupled tailplane and powerful engine. Due to the rudder's influence on controls, you use the pedals significantly in coordinated turns. Adverse yaw is clearly present on the Breese (though perhaps less than similar higher-dihedral designs).
Performance
Climb; Glide; Sink; Cruise/stall/max speeds; Endurance; Range; Maneuverability.
Pros - The Breese, even with its double-surface wing, excels at low-over-the-field flying. Flying from water or ground, you won't spend a long time earthbound. With the HKS, climb is close to 1,000 fpm. Despite solid performance, the Breese DS is appropriate for beginning pilots. Cruise at 60 to 65 mph is very achievable.
Cons - Speed range, though perfectly acceptable for the type, is only about 2.5:1 (4:1 is considered excellent). Top speed is only 74 mph, not too fast for a cross-country flight. Consumes fuel at a faster rate than more enclosed aircraft (though an optional enclosure may improve upon this).
Stability
Stall recovery and characteristics; Dampening; Spiral stability; Adverse yaw qualities.
Pros - Stalls were all highly predictable nonevents. Steel (stainless on test Breese DS) surrounds cockpit to better protect pilot - and makes for a strong structure. Test plane was parachute equipped. Four-point seat belts were appreciated as well.
Cons - Adverse yaw is significant. Misapplication of controls can cause some wallowing at lower speeds. With the high engine and thrust line, the HKS-powered Breese DS noses over on rapid throttle movement.
Overall
Addresses the questions: "Will a buyer get what he/she expects to buy, and did the designer/builder achieve the chosen goal?"
Pros - A proven design, made even stronger with larger tubing, with 4-stroke engine and popular accessories (such as electric start) for $19,995 for a fly-away aircraft is a very fair price. Strutted look is what many buyers seek. Long- range fuel tanks also standard.
Cons - You'll have to N-number a Breese DS HKS (but factory has a builder-assistance program). Buyers in cold climates won't much care for the wide-open cockpit (without optional enclosure). This open, simple type of design may cause more challenges at resale time.
Twenty-something years of ultralight flying have seen many changes take place in our ultralights. At the beginning of the ultralight industry we had craft such as Eagles, Weedhoppers, and Quicksilvers powered by engines like the 15-hp Yamaha, Mac 101, and Chrysler. Of these, only Quicksilver remains vibrant. Here in 2004, we have aircraft like the Breese DS with its 60-hp HKS 700E 4-stroke engine. It may look like a Quicksilver but it’s a different flying animal. M-Squared’s Jay Stevens gave me a checkout in the single-seat Breese with its Japanese 4-stroke powerplant and it proved to be a very satisfying experience. Strong and Powerful The resemblance to Quicksilver, especially the California company’s strut-braced model, is obvious to most ultralight veterans but Breese manufacturer M-Squared has steadily changed their design. Looks, therefore, can be deceiving. The use of struts first set apart the designs of Paul Mather, proprietor of M-Squared. A tailplane that uses no cable bracing added to the different appearance.