Many excellent aircraft may be headed our way
Parlez-vous Française? Sprechen Sie Deutsche? Parlate Italiano? Fortunately, to understand European recreational aircraft you don’t need to speak French, German, or Italian. Yet the light-sport aircraft (LSA) that may interest you could come from countries where the mother tongue isn’t English.
Welcome to the globalized
world of light-sport
aircraft where the workers
who built your plane may speak
Polish, Russian, Hungarian, or
Latvian in addition to French,
German, or Italian.
Though many intriguing
ultralights come from Europe and
Americans have seen a few of these,
many are a complete surprise to
Yankee pilots. That will change.
Last year after EAA AirVenture
Oshkosh 2002 ended, I traveled to
Blois (pronounced Blwah), France, a
town about 200 kilometers south of
Paris. There I attended the 22nd
salon (or air show) that organizers
present at this location each year in
late summer. Let’s take a walk
around the salon at Blois.
What Aircraft Look Interesting?
People arriving at air shows or
those at home who can’t go often
ask the question, “What’s new at the
show?” Usually those of us in the
media have some idea about the new
flying machines, as it is our job to
find them and tell readers about
them in articles like this one.
At AirVenture, Sun ’n Fun, the
Northwest Regional EAA Fly-In, or
any of the other fine shows around
the country, that job can be
demanding. The challenge is to find
the few genuinely new or
outstanding aircraft from the
hundreds or thousands in
attendance. At Blois, the job was
easy. Almost every aircraft seemed
new, and many were uncommonly
shapely and beautiful. The diversity
was marvelous.
“White, composite, and from
overseas” remains a lingering theme
this year. In Europe, white-andcomposite
seems to rule, yet they
don’t own the market. I saw several
new trikes, including the Pegasus
Quik, indicating that trikes are still
popular as well.
A French company is offering a
super-basic “103” aircraft even
though our simplest U.S. rule
doesn’t apply in Europe. A
Slovenian company showed one of
the most beautiful and practical
motorgliders to emerge from the
category. Do you know where
Slovenia is? (Hint: It’s a picturesque
country east of Italy near that
country’s northern border.)
Even with those lightplanes made
of more conventional shapes, the
diversity continues with all-metal
planes, all-fiberglass planes, allcarbon
fiber planes, ones with mixed
steel and fiberglass, aluminum and
steel. Two of these aircraft featured
retractable gear.
About the only thing Blois didn’t
offer was floatplanes. A few floats for
trikes were displayed, but their
impact on visitors was modest. Why,
I wondered? Later I was told France
only has two lakes in the entire
country that permit floatplane
landings. No wonder floats aren’t
popular in France. My home state of
Minnesota has over 15,000 lakes,
and you can land on just about all of
them. Quite a difference.
Aerocar developer Molt Taylor is
quoted as saying that “An airplane
will get you from one place you
don’t want to be to another place
you don’t want to be…the airport.”
While devised as an argument for his
airplane-to-car convertible, it is
nonetheless true that airports in the
United States aren’t often a place you
and your family might want to
spend the day. Yet at airfields across
Europe, a restaurant is often part of
the facilities. And I don’t mean some
vending machine station; I mean a
restaurant that the locals like to
frequent for excellent food and
drink. When the planes were tied
down at the end of the day in Blois,
many of us headed over to the
restaurant for a chilled beverage,
served to us in a pleasant outdoor
seating area.
A Confluence of Events
Why have American and
European light aircraft undergone
such different development phases?
The simple answer is “because they
had to,” but a more accurate reply is
that three primary events drove the
change.
I have followed European aviation
for many years. In the early days of
ultralight aviation, Euro designers
pumped out numerous versions of
trikes, each with increasing
sophistication. In those days,
American companies supplied most
of the fixed-wing designs that
European pilots flew.
That began to change in the mid-
1980s when European authorities
started to impose noise regulations.
Yankee designers didn’t pursue this
change vigorously and, as a result,
more European-created fixed-wing
ultralights began to show up at their
airfields. The first ones looked like
American designs but with more
attention to noise reduction. These
designs succeeded nicely; European
aircraft are much quieter than U.S.
models. Of course, you pay for this hardware in higher prices and higher
empty weights. Eventually those
Euro ultralights began their own
evolution to light planes.
The second event involved fuel
prices that began to rise all over the
European continent. Today, Euro
aviators pay $8-10 per gallon of
aviation fuel. Those who can use
auto fuel are luckier, but they still
have to pay $4-6 a gallon. The
wholesale price of fuel is essentially
the same all over the world; the
difference is in taxes. With these
high prices (or taxes), fuel efficiency
became ever-more important to
Europeans. Again, Yankee designers
who see auto gas prices of $1.50 a
gallon at home weren’t motivated to
put extraordinary efforts into
reducing fuel consumption.
Third, the low impact of general
aviation in Europe must be
considered. To buy and operate a
Cessna 172 would be prohibitive for
all but the most affluent European
aviators, much like buying and
flying a new Bonanza is out of reach
for most American pilots. A Cessna
172 typically rents for $150 an hour
and burns 8-10 gallons. New
European “ultralights” (they’re
definition of an ultralight more
closely matches our proposed lightsport
aircraft category) fly as fast on
half the fuel or less. That’s a big
savings, and you can afford the
aircraft purchase price.
So Europe went from building just
trikes to building trikes plus quiet
three-axis aircraft that evolved into
their “ultralights” of today, which
we perceive as illustrating that
“white, composite, and from
overseas” theme. These aircraft came
about partly to address the lack of
used Cessna 172s and to cope with
the high cost of fuel for a population
that wants to use these light aircraft
to tour around Europe.
A fourth factor is a sleeper. After
the Soviet Union fell a dozen years
ago, the marketplace was suddenly
flooded with talented engineers and
workers displaced from their state
aviation industry jobs. They work for
a fraction of western wages and yet bring many skills to the job. Combine this hunger for work with the West’s interest in developing efficient touring aircraft, and you have a formula for the development of more exotic light aircraft than are found elsewhere in the world.
That brings us to the European Union (EU) of today. It has the aircraft and systems to produce them. Most have been through some level of certification and are manufactured by people who understand certified aircraft production. Add to that experience the coming light-sport aircraft rule, and you have identified why the path from Europe to America is becoming well worn.
The Light-Sport Aircraft Appeal
Europeans want a piece of the U.S. action. For one, the United States is far and away the world’s largest aviation market in all categories. The EU countries altogether boast slightly more population than the USA, and the number of sport aircraft flying in all EU countries is roughly the same as the USA. But America overwhelmingly dominates in the general aviation segment with about 70 percent of the world’s fleet. But with sport aircraft, the EU is a close competitor. In essence, then, the USA represents a potential doubling of the market for European-designed aircraft.
One way to review what Europe has to offer is to join me in a photo tour of the offerings shown at Blois. I’ve selected 19 of the most interesting aircraft I saw at the 2002 show. The range is considerable, but my focus was on new aircraft I hadn’t often or ever seen.
A few of the popular European aircraft were not included as Americans already know them. With each photo, I’ll present a few brief comments and a way to get more information. I have not assembled the aircraft into any particular order. You’ll know what you like when you see it.
It will almost be like going to France!
Europe Embraces Light-Sport Aircraft
Published in Experimenter Magazine
Leave a Reply